Showing posts with label youtube. Show all posts
Showing posts with label youtube. Show all posts

Thursday, September 06, 2007

More about “Participatory Marketing” and YouTube: Leveraging Reputation and Authenticity Through Social Network

...People articulate their identity by creating self-presentations, which include endorsements of various objects of material and symbolic culture—favorite music, TV shows, fashion items, video games, beverages, etc. YouTube and other online social networks are very successful in scaling up self-presentations and mobilizing forms of "joint attention", enabling their users to pay attention to each other and learn what other people like or dislike, and discover with whom they are most "alike". These features provide a ground for creating novel advertising strategies that could leverage the “wealth of the network” and capitalize on lateral conversations between users and on users' reputations...

One of the main challenges for advertisers is to create a sense of authenticity, which affirms the content of the ad as genuine and validates the voice of the advertiser as credible. In any kind of rhetorical discourse, not just in advertisements, people attempt to authenticate both their message and themselves as the source of the message. People authenticate their messages by providing relevant information and using various rhetorical tools to construct persuasive arguments. Their credibility, however, also depends on their existing reputation with their audience, as well as their ability to do impression management while engaging their audience. Advertisers have a serious problem in validating their credibility, due to their status as a paid agent, rather than an authentic speaker.

New media have created a new participatory culture and changed the ways people create and share knowledge. The traditional “top-down” models of knowledge production and dissemination are being replaced by more distributed models which consist of user generated content that is collectively arbitrated through lateral conversations between users. The following YouTube video illustrates how those emergent "participatory cultures" may affect the issues of authenticity and reputation in the relation between advertisers and consumers:



YouTube and other social media have empowered users who have grown skeptical about the top-down creation and distribution of information. Consumers nowadays seem to require a different relationship with advertisers, a relationship in which they will be a partner in a dialogue rather than a "target" of the advertisement. YouTube has a large and diverse community of users who seem to be very passionate about the things they care about—their political views, favorite TV shows, music, ideas, etc. Participants in YouTube also seem to take pride in performing their expertise and sharing the knowledge they create. They have strong opinions and they can be very creative in expressing them.

Here are two ideas for advertising strategies that attempt to leverage these features of the YouTube community:

1) Dialogue with participants: Repurposing of professionally made ads
In addition to watching sophisticated InVideo ads, YouTubers could engage in a creative dialogue with such ads and re-appropriate them for self-expression. For example, YouTube could enable its users to re-purpose professionally made commercial videos and create remix and mashups. Although some of those user-repurposed ads may turn to be parodies that are critiquing the ad, a critique on YouTube means virality, attention, an enhanced product awareness, and not necessarily negative attitudes toward the product.

2) User’s reputation as a leverage of authenticity
People articulate their identity by creating self-presentations, which include endorsements of various objects of material and symbolic culture—favorite music, TV shows, fashion items, video games, beverages, etc. YouTube and other online social networks are very successful in scaling up self-presentations and mobilizing forms of "joint attention", enabling their users to pay attention to each other and learn what other people like or dislike, and discover with whom they are most "alike". Several online applications have already taken advantage of that feature. For example, a Facebook application ""ProductPulse"" enables its users to rate their favorite brands, movies, bands, or even TV shows in categories like “love it/hate it/want it/need info”. Users can also check out what products their friends are using and get recommendations and original reviews from the whole productpulse userbase... Furthermore, all rated products have links to online stores for "instant gratification" :-)

By creatively appropriating and applying these and similar ideas, YouTube and other online social network sites could create radically novel advertising strategies that would leverage the “wealth of the network” and capitalize on lateral conversations between users.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

Participatory Marketing and YouTube InVideo Ads: Still Missing the Long Tail…


...YouTube has made an important step in creating a novel advertising model that presupposes an active and engaged user. In order to fully leverage the potential of user-generated content and the potential of YouTube as a networked community, YouTube will need to innovate even more and create even more participatory models of marketing in which users are not “targets”, but creative co-participants in product promotion..


A few days ago YouTube launched an innovative method of web advertising, “InVideo ads”, which consists of transparent animated flash “overlays” that are superimposed on selected videos. The method reflects a delicate balance between the demands for optimal user experience and the inherently intrusive nature of advertisements. Here is how YouTube introduced the InVideo ads to their community:

“…Today we're offering select partners the ability to incorporate YouTube InVideo ads into their content. These are animated overlays that appear on the bottom 20 percent of a video. If you're interested by what you see there, clicking on the overlay launches a deeper interactive video ad that we think is relevant and entertaining. (The video you were watching is temporarily paused.) If you choose not to click on the overlay, it will simply disappear, so that you're in full control of your YouTube experience...”

NewTeeVee showed screen shots of YouTube experiments with InVideo ads already in May and the recent version seems to be more animated than the previous one. I saw the 20th Century Fox's The Simpsons running on Warner Music Group video and must admit that the ad was pretty non-intrusive. In some ways it was actually funny and enjoyable to watch Homer Simpson running over the screen, and it felt almost like a parody mashup produced by a teenager who wants to amuse his friends.


The InVideo ads invite the user to engage at a deeper level than traditional web ads (YouTube claims they have five to ten times the click-through rates on InVideo Ads versus traditional display ads). YouTube realized that when their users start a video, they need time to get into it, and thus they delay the InVideo ad display by 10-15 seconds. If they interrupt or display ads before that window, viewers are unlikely to engage, and are more likely to abandon videos as they do with preroll ads. When a user does engage with the ad and click to expand it, 75% return to watch to the end of the video. Shashi Seth, YouTube Group Product Manager, suggests that the InVideo ads can be targeted based on user demographics (age and gender), location, day part, and content genre. In addition to being able to target users, marketers would also be provided with metrics on click-throughs and ad viewers, as well as YouTube community metrics (links, comments, favorites, subscriptions, etc.).

YouTube has apparently created a non-intrusive and user-engaging method of in-video advertisement that has received fairly positive reviews from advertisers, publishers, and some bloggers. However, many YouTube users have openly expressed their dissatisfaction and threatened to leave. Although some analysts argue that InVideo advertising will eventually alienate YouTubers and cause them to leave the site, in the short run, I do not anticipate a massive migration from YouTube, since so far only a relatively small number of professionally made videos are targeted with the InVideo ads. In the long run, however, YouTube will have to find a way to monetize user-generated content from the long tail of DIY videos. Such videos are often of low quality, and overlaying them with professionally made InVideo ads may not be as appealing to viewers or advertisers.

YouTube has made an important step in creating a novel advertising model that presupposes an active and engaged user. In order to fully leverage the potential of user-generated content and the potential of YouTube as a networked community, YouTube will need to innovate even more and create even more participatory models of marketing in which the users are not “targets”, but creative co-participants in product promotion (e.g., “word of mouth” marketing). The opportunity seems to be to engage their audience of videomakers not merely as consumers of brand messages, but as authentic producers and viral distributors of them. More about participatory marketing in my next post.